Knight0440
08-17-2005, 12:44 AM
source: Stopping West Nile Virus: Is Pesticide Spraying Doing More Harm than Good? (http://chicago.indymedia.org/newswire/display_any/61522) (for links/photos)
by CIMC - TF / Julie Peterson
11 Aug 2005
On Monday night community members (photos: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5) from the Lincoln Square neighborhood congregated outside the Streets and Sanitation building located on Lawrence Ave. in an attempt to stop the spraying of Anvil in their neighborhood.
Anvil is a toxic pesticide that kills adult mosquitoes on contact. It also poses health risks to children, seniors, pregnant women and asthmatics. If inhaled it can cause a multiplicity of symptoms and has suspected links to breast cancer.
A press release issued by the public health department said that city traps infected with West Nile Virus jumped 33 percent last week. Dr. William Paul, acting public health commissioner, is quoted as saying, "Spraying to kill adult mosquitoes is a sensible and effective component of an integrated pest management program."
Currently there are four confirmed cases of West Nile in Illinois, one being in Chicago.
Paul arrived at the scene around 7:30 p.m. to speak with the corporate media. After 50 to 75 trucks (photos: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4), sporting the Clarke Mosquito Control logo escorted by city trucks had left to spray the North Side neighborhoods, Paul agreed to see 5 community members to discuss their concerns.
In the meeting, Paul stated that the automated phone calls were ineffective in notifying the public about the sprayings, and according to Julie Peterson, teacher and community member, "Paul expressed regret that notification of the second spraying was not disseminated at all." Finally, Paul agreed he would "commit to public meetings" regarding future spraying.
Peterson stated in an email that, "[Spraying is] a violent thing; to spray children playing in their front yard, people walking in their neighborhood, to spray people while they eat in a sidewalk cafe, to spray people through the open windows of their cars, and who have no idea about what the department of public health knows; that this chemical has been linked to breast cancer, that this chemical is going to make it harder for people to breath, that they have been ordered indoors and that nobody cares if they didn't get the message."
Many community members felt that Paul's presence was more of a political smokescreen than an actual concern for public health. Is mass spraying effective? Even Paul, according to community member Marty Glass, "was unsure of the level of effectiveness."
"Somebody is making a lot of money selling the chemical, spraying the chemical, and somebody is making the decision that the people are too stupid to understand that the people dying from West Nile may be replaced with people dying from breast cancer or other types of cancer or toxicities," Peterson wrote. "The people I've talked to are angry that this decision was made without public notification, debate, or education."
by CIMC - TF / Julie Peterson
11 Aug 2005
On Monday night community members (photos: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5) from the Lincoln Square neighborhood congregated outside the Streets and Sanitation building located on Lawrence Ave. in an attempt to stop the spraying of Anvil in their neighborhood.
Anvil is a toxic pesticide that kills adult mosquitoes on contact. It also poses health risks to children, seniors, pregnant women and asthmatics. If inhaled it can cause a multiplicity of symptoms and has suspected links to breast cancer.
A press release issued by the public health department said that city traps infected with West Nile Virus jumped 33 percent last week. Dr. William Paul, acting public health commissioner, is quoted as saying, "Spraying to kill adult mosquitoes is a sensible and effective component of an integrated pest management program."
Currently there are four confirmed cases of West Nile in Illinois, one being in Chicago.
Paul arrived at the scene around 7:30 p.m. to speak with the corporate media. After 50 to 75 trucks (photos: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4), sporting the Clarke Mosquito Control logo escorted by city trucks had left to spray the North Side neighborhoods, Paul agreed to see 5 community members to discuss their concerns.
In the meeting, Paul stated that the automated phone calls were ineffective in notifying the public about the sprayings, and according to Julie Peterson, teacher and community member, "Paul expressed regret that notification of the second spraying was not disseminated at all." Finally, Paul agreed he would "commit to public meetings" regarding future spraying.
Peterson stated in an email that, "[Spraying is] a violent thing; to spray children playing in their front yard, people walking in their neighborhood, to spray people while they eat in a sidewalk cafe, to spray people through the open windows of their cars, and who have no idea about what the department of public health knows; that this chemical has been linked to breast cancer, that this chemical is going to make it harder for people to breath, that they have been ordered indoors and that nobody cares if they didn't get the message."
Many community members felt that Paul's presence was more of a political smokescreen than an actual concern for public health. Is mass spraying effective? Even Paul, according to community member Marty Glass, "was unsure of the level of effectiveness."
"Somebody is making a lot of money selling the chemical, spraying the chemical, and somebody is making the decision that the people are too stupid to understand that the people dying from West Nile may be replaced with people dying from breast cancer or other types of cancer or toxicities," Peterson wrote. "The people I've talked to are angry that this decision was made without public notification, debate, or education."